Oct 20, 2021

DSCI Whitepaper on Encryption | Executive Summary

Encryption ensures protection of information and communications in different spheres – personal, commercial, and in the public sector. It secures data against unwanted access, helps ensure the confidentiality of data, and delivers trust in the digital economy. The paper titled "Encryption and the Digital Economy: Balancing Security, Privacy and National Security" offers a holistic viewpoint to the more extensive encryption debate by engaging with stakeholders within academia, government, law enforcement, as well as industry.

The paper endeavours to widen the horizon around encryption deliberations and highlights the technical, moral, and law enforcement complexities encryption creates as we attempt to secure personal data and digital services through E2EE.

It also provides a detailed overview on the regulatory landscape in India and around the globe on the benefits and challenges of encryption and encryption challenging interventions. The paper offers a comprehensive breakdown of various facets, ranging from encryption's historical and legal context to the technical and constitutional considerations of breaking E2EE and traceability. It also advises the user to look at encryption as a complex tool with a broad and varied impact that has both primary effects and consequences and secondary implications in criminal justice and law enforcement.

Apart from painting a clear picture of the encryption debate and its ramifications, the paper also lists recommendations/alternative solutions to encryption challenging interventions. Some of which are highlighted below:

  • Focusing on data at rest rather than data in transit
  • Establishing clear rules for government accessing data on the end devices through hacking
  • The requirement to trace the originator of information should be optional
  • Building capacity of law enforcement agencies
  • Instituting appropriate process safeguards under the interception framework
  • Clarifying the scope of technical assistance under the Decryption Rules
  • Removing the restriction on the usage of bulk encryption
pdf-iconDSCI Whitepaper on Encryption | Executive Summary